GEICO vs Amica Mutual Insurance: Who is Cheaper

Comparing insurance companies like GEICO and Amica Mutual Insurance can be complex as rates can vary significantly based on numerous factors like location, driving history, age, coverage levels, and more. While I can’t give you precise rates due to the multitude of variables involved, I can provide an overview of factors that often influence pricing between these two insurers.


GEICO, known for its ubiquitous advertising campaigns and competitive rates, often appeals to customers seeking affordable coverage. As a direct-to-consumer insurer, GEICO leverages technology and streamlined processes to potentially offer lower premiums. Their wide array of discounts, such as multi-policy, multi-vehicle, good driver, and safety feature discounts, can help policyholders save money.

The company’s large size and extensive marketing budget enable them to offer competitive rates to a broad customer base. Additionally, GEICO’s online tools and mobile app make managing policies and claims convenient, appealing to tech-savvy individuals seeking a straightforward experience.

However, despite their generally affordable rates, the actual cost for an individual can vary significantly depending on personal circumstances and location. Factors like credit history, driving record, and the specific coverage options chosen can all influence the final premium.

Amica Mutual Insurance:

On the other hand, Amica Mutual Insurance is renowned for its exceptional customer service and high customer satisfaction ratings. While not as prominently advertised as GEICO, Amica prides itself on personalized service and comprehensive coverage options. They emphasize customer relationships and often tailor policies to individual needs rather than offering one-size-fits-all solutions.

Amica’s approach to underwriting tends to focus on a more thorough evaluation of risk factors, potentially resulting in slightly higher initial premiums compared to some competitors. However, they often attract customers seeking superior coverage, reliability, and attentive service.

Amica is also known for its dividend policies, occasionally returning a portion of profits to policyholders. This feature might provide long-term cost savings but might not affect the immediate premium cost.

Determining Who Is Cheaper:

Determining which insurer is cheaper, GEICO or Amica, is challenging without specific individual information. GEICO tends to target affordability and can offer competitive rates, especially for those seeking basic coverage and looking to save on premiums. Amica, while potentially slightly pricier upfront, may provide more comprehensive coverage and personalized service, potentially yielding better value in the long run.

Ultimately, the best way to find the most cost-effective insurance is to obtain personalized quotes from both companies based on your specific circumstances. Comparing the quotes in terms of coverage levels, deductibles, and available discounts will help in making an informed decision about which insurer provides the most value for your individual needs. Remember, the ‘cheaper’ option might not always be the most cost-effective in the long term if it compromises on coverage or service quality.

Can I cancel GEICO car insurance at any time?

Yes, you can cancel GEICO car insurance at any time. The cancellation process typically involves contacting GEICO through phone, online, or in-person at an agent’s office. You might need to provide specific policy information and the reason for cancellation. Refunds for prepaid premiums are usually prorated, minus any fees, and can vary based on state regulations and policy terms. Ensure to review your policy documents for any cancellation fees or penalties. It’s advisable to have alternative coverage in place before canceling to avoid gaps in insurance. Be mindful that your driving history and lapse in coverage could affect future insurance rates.

Can I cancel my GEICO policy online or on the app?

Absolutely, cancelling your GEICO policy is quite straightforward using their online portal or mobile app. First, log in to your GEICO account on their website or through the app. Navigate to the policy you wish to cancel, usually under the “Manage Policy” section. Look for an option like “Cancel Policy” or “End Coverage.” Follow the prompts, providing any required information. Review the cancellation terms and ensure you understand any potential fees or consequences. Confirm your cancellation request. Remember, it’s essential to check if there are any specific cancellation requirements based on your policy type or state regulations to avoid any complications.


Leave a Comment